Liberal Democracy Needs Propaganda Too
The Democratic National Committee's quiet effort to spread anti-GOP clips on social media worked. Good.
The Democratic National Committee's quiet effort to spread anti-GOP clips on social media worked. Good.
A lot of liberal-left online posting over the past two disorienting years has constituted a gnashing of virtual teeth over the vast, hulking, billionaire-funded right-wing media apparatus that shapes American political reality and puts pro-democracy forces in a defensive crouch from which offense is impossible.
There are any number of cable news outlets, most prominently Fox News, operating as the communication arm of the Republican Party, dressing up increasingly fascist propaganda as news items, normalizing explicitly anti-democracy messaging, and harnessing the power of negative polarization to keep the GOP a competitive national party despite its immensely unpopular platform and policies—as far as Republicans even have policies anymore.
Twitter was bought and broken and turned into a horrifying fascist echo chamber by the guy who all but single-handedly funds the Republican Party.
Meta platforms, owned by a dead-eyed fascist collaborator, are awash in brain-breaking far-right misinformation, the kind that creates an unreality in which Republican solutions to wholly-invented problems are not only legitimate, but indeed necessary.
The information war between Republicans and Democrats is no war at all. It’s a never-ending massacre. Democrats in the Trump era have largely ceded control of reality-generating algorithms to their opponents, who despise multiracial democracy and want nothing more than to weaponize those algorithms to repeal the 20th century. It is remarkable that Republicans could suffer an historic midterm election defeat with such a powerful propaganda machine at their disposal. Lived experience, I suppose, sometimes trumps algorithms.
When it was recently revealed by Semafor that the Democratic National Committee is dabbling in a little pro-democracy propaganda, I was heartened, excited, hopeful that proponents of liberal democracy had finally got the hint that propagandizing a public drowning in fascist online content was the way to go. In early 2025, as Trump began his second term with a double-barrel assault on foundational constitutional law, the DNC, according to Semafor, “relaunched its rapid response online efforts under a new brand, @FactPostNews, an account intentionally designed to look like an independent news aggregator, not a messaging arm of the party.”
“If you talked to the admins of some accounts, they wouldn’t even realize that they were essentially pushing DNC messaging to their audiences who were not explicitly political."
—Paulina Mangubat, head of content and creative at the DNC
Mangubat noted that the DNC had hired researchers to monitor and dig up negative material on Republicans, largely in the form of video clips from little-noticed interviews on podcasts or public channels. It needed a better way, though, to seed that information to its audiences and voters online. So the committee created a clip library, and began to grow its group of unpaid influencers. The DNC would distribute what it saw as embarrassing or damaging clips of Trump or other administration officials to its one-way Signal group chat, which by October had swelled to more than 700 creators. Instead of sharing talking points or bland DNC messaging, the national party’s communications team decided to simply share clips and let the creators decide whether or how to use them.
Hey, I thought while reading the Semafor report, Democratic Party officials—so stodgy and stuck in their ways, so careful and afraid and professional in all the worst ways—finally get it. I took a quick look at the @FactPostNews account on Bluesky, which includes the Democratic Party’s website in its bio, to see what, exactly, it pumps into the information ecosystem.
There was a post about newly-anointed Republican House leader Jim Jordan’s connections to sexual abuse among wrestlers at Ohio State University; one post highlighted falling crime rates in New York City under Mayor Zohran Mamdani; a photo of convicted rapist Russell Brand alongside Dr. Oz and RFK Jr.; another in which Katie Miller tells JD Vance that Stephen Miller only eats mayonnaise; and one in which a teenage Stephen Miller denigrates janitors who work at his school.
It struck me as darkly funny that the DNC in January 2025 announced the launch of @FactPostNews. They weren’t even trying to be sneaky about seeding the party’s various messages on an account that to the average social media scroller had no connection to the DNC. That this announcement went unseen—even those who follow politics closely—all but proves that everything Democrats push online is sucked into a black hole. Almost nothing the party does or says gets the benefit of an algorithmic megaphone the way that far-right messaging does.
Mostly, the @FactPostNews account reminds its followers that Republican officials are awful, deceitful people with no redeeming qualities. Nothing on the account was factually untrue. Everything was designed to make Democrats look good and Republicans look bad—you know, the very point of effective propaganda.
Propaganda, after all, only has its intended effect when it’s as true as possible. Even the Nazi Party understood this. As Jonathan D. Teubner and Paul W. Gleason wrote in the Hedgehog Review in 2023:
“Note the absence of any mention of truth or falsehood. Instead, these classic definitions place propaganda within the airier realm of rumor, report, picture, suggestion, and symbol. A baldfaced lie would theoretically be open to falsification, which would leave the speaker exposed and discredited. So the skillful propagandist instead works by insinuation, by spinning the significance of events in one way or another, by bringing the reader, listener, or viewer around to a particular point of view. Propaganda creates a general atmosphere in which a particular conclusion seems undeniable, even though it is suggested rather than stated. What matters is not the facts, but their significance.”
This is precisely why the right has had such success in its propaganda online and on cable news. There has not, until very recently, been any pushback from those who support the continued existence of multiracial representative democracy.
There is no point in pretending fact checkers can stop the spigot of right-wing propaganda spewing out of every news channel and social media site. The fact checkers, as Gleason and Teubner wrote, did not save American democracy from the authoritarian threat. They wrote:
“Since much of what skillful propagandists say will be true on a literal level, the fact-checker will be unable to refute them. Second, no matter how well-intentioned or convincing, the fact-check will also spread the initial claims further. Third, even if the fact-checker manages to catch a few inaccuracies, the larger picture and suggestion will remain in place, and it is this suggestion that moves minds and hearts, and eventually actions.”
Since the nightmare that was the 2024 election, discourse on Bluesky, the social platform teeming with well-meaning liberals who decamped from the fascist recruitment website formerly known as Twitter, has largely revolved around ways in which Democratic politicians and candidates can better message to the American public in our disorienting and fragmented media environment. Every few weeks over these past two years, Bluesky’s amateur political strategists—including me—have bounced around ideas for how to break through in an information environment saturated with right-wing misinformation. The ways in which we might break the right’s hold on how people perceive political issues in our newly competitive authoritarian landscape has been a prominent feature of Bluesky since 2024.
And yet, I sensed more than a little discomfort about the DNC filtering its messaging through online influencers and social accounts that did not bear the party’s name. Folks on Bluesky squirmed when they read through the Semafor report on the DNC finally putting posters in charge of their messaging machine. I asked Daniel Gilmore, a media studies and communications professor at NYU, why so many liberals appeared deeply uncomfortable with the DNC’s dabbling in propaganda. Gilmore said:
"I understand why some people find that to be a bit distasteful, but it very much feels like a ‘don't hate the player, hate the game’ situation. This is the media landscape that politics exists in currently. Democrats didn't invent that. They can either skate to where the puck is on reaching voters or they can cede that landscape to Republicans, which, inadvertently is basically what happened from the mid 2010s through 2024."
The liberal griping about Democrats’ inability to break the right wing’s domination of media narratives might best be seen in the everlasting search for “the left’s Joe Rogan,” a normal, sometimes dumb, often relatable bro who can talk to his fellow bros about why they should support this or that. Young men—especially young men—flocked to Trump in 2024 after backing Joe Biden in 2020 in no small part because Rogan told them to. Rogan’s interview with Trump, which netted nearly 40 million views in its first 72 hours on YouTube, normalized a deeply abnormal presidential candidate who made no qualms about unwinding American democracy. Rogan made it OK to vote for the fascist. In fact, he made it cool as hell.
While the search for a left-wing Joe Rogan continues—although some would say Hasan Piker has filled the role quite nicely since 2024—the Democratic Party is seeking ways to influence the country’s electorate in ways that might not be described as forthright or terribly honest. This, I think, is contrary to how most American liberals believe the game should be played. And maybe they’re right. In an ideal information environment that is not poisoned by untold billions of dollars from right-wing interests, straightforward battling between the country’s two major parties would not be waged through shadowy proxies. You wouldn’t have to wonder if your favorite podcaster or YouTuber was coordinating with one of the country’s two major political parties in discussing certain hot-button political topics in a certain way.
As Gilmore says, that’s simply not what we have today:
"Ultimately I think that, besides the broader psychological drama people have around the Democratic Party, what we're seeing expressed here in unease with this stuff is an unease with the way that social media operates as an informational landscape in our lives and, honestly, I don't disagree. There's a lot to not like about this landscape! But again, Democrats’ responsibility is to reach voters via the tools and avenues available to them, so here we are."
People have to be told why liberal democracy is good for them and their families: The social and economic stability it can provide, the legal protections it can offer to those who most need it, the protections against those in power stripping people of their bodily autonomy and their right to self determination. They have to be told explicitly when a movement or politician threatens those arrangements. They have to be told which ones are the bad guys and which ones are the good guys. People only understand the world through stories. So give them one: Democracy vs. autocracy, dignity vs. oppression, constitutional rule of law vs. totalitarian lawlessness, good vs. evil.
These are stories, I think, that need to be told by whatever means necessary.
Featured image is "FDR-September-30-1934," author unknown 1934.
Sign up for the newsletter and get our latest stories delivered straight to your inbox.