Reckoning With the Communist Legacy of Violence

The moral gravity of wrongs requires an intervention, and this intervention may not always come at an opportune time.

Reckoning With the Communist Legacy of Violence

‘‘Men and women characterized by the adjective ‘liberal’ condemn brutal repression and mass murder’’ (The Struggle for a Decent Politics, p. 37). This seems a low bar for politics, and indeed for individual morality, but as Michael Walzer elucidates in his book, violence remains a powerful—and some might add irrepressible—human attraction, especially among those who seek to distinguish themselves by their militancy. 

Every now and then we hear prominent figures online either endorse violence or valorize those who do. This callous tendency to contextualize or excuse mass murder has found its way back to certain sectors of the left, where a commitment to ‘revolutionary action’ is seen as inseparable from armed resistance and a willingness to engage in violence. Hasan Piker, a popular streamer and political activist, received criticism when an old video of him praising the Chinese dictator Mao Zedong resurfaced. Other ideologically-aligned political personalities have also come under scrutiny for similar comments regarding Hamas. 

A look at the political career of the Chinese Communist Party chairman, gone now for a half-century, immediately reveals why any praise in his direction can spark controversy. Mao pursued his own form of winning guerilla warfare, and then he masterminded an economic revolution—the so-called Great Leap Forward—which led to the starvation and death of 20 to 30 million people within four painful years. Mao’s dictatorial leadership created an environment of deep paranoia and fear, which made it extraordinarily difficult for authorities to address the unfolding crisis. 

When Liu Shaoqui, Mao’s second in command, visited his hometown to see for himself if the reports of starvation were true, town officials tried their best to hide any evidence of hunger: ‘‘Along the road leading to Liu’s hometown, starving peasants had torn the bark off trees to eat, so officials plastered the tree trunks with yellow mud and straw to conceal the scars’’ (Why Communism Failed, p. 185). To make matters worse, Mao further devastated China’s ecosystem by calling for the mass slaughter of sparrows, a move that allowed locusts and pests to decimate the already disheveled crops, further aggravating the prolonged man-made problem of mass hunger in the countryside.

Support Liberal Currents

For a limited time, redeem these offers and get access to everything we write, including print copies of The Reconstruction Papers.

Learn More

Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to Liberal Currents.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.